A breakdown of what reviewers and analysts are saying about Ghost of Yōtei (also spelled “Yotei”)

on

 


🎮 What is Ghost of Yōtei?

  • It’s a PS5 exclusive action-adventure / open-world game by Sucker Punch, positioned as a spiritual successor to Ghost of Tsushima.

  • The story is set around 1603 in the Ezo region (Hokkaidō area), following Atsu, a mercenary whose family was slaughtered by a group called the Yōtei Six. She embarks on a quest for revenge.

  • The game retains many features from Tsushima (e.g. exploration, combat, open world systems) but attempts to “evolve” them: more naturalistic world design, choice in order of objectives, new presentation modes (Kurosawa, Miike, Watanabe modes) for stylistic variation.

  • The developers emphasize that the game “isn’t going to rush you through anything” — i.e. more player freedom and pacing control than in some typical open-world games.

  • The main campaign is expected to take ~ 25 hours (for the core story) with much more content for completionists.

👍 Strengths & Highlights

  1. Beautifully Realized World & Presentation
    Many reviews praise the visual and atmospheric craftsmanship. The landscapes, lighting effects, weather, and environmental detail are often called “mesmerizing.”
    The addition of presentation modes (e.g. Watanabe mode, black-and-white “Kurosawa Mode”) is seen as a smart way to vary the visual tone.

  2. Refined Combat & Gameplay Systems
    Combat is frequently described as slick, responsive, and deeper than its predecessor. The variety of weapons (katanas, kusarigama, etc.) encourages combining styles.
    Stealth mechanics and assassination moves are satisfying.
    The “Guiding Wind” navigation from Tsushima is back, praised for keeping the map less cluttered and making the world feel more organic.

  3. Strong Protagonist / Emotional Core
    Atsu is seen as a more grounded, emotionally driven lead compared to Jin Sakai (from Tsushima). Reviewers note that the motivation is personal and visceral, which helps anchor the narrative.
    The storytelling is generally praised for bringing depth to side quests and for creating narrative weight in the main revenge arc.

  4. Critical Reception & Metrics

    • On OpenCritic, 97% of critics recommend the game.

    • Metacritic reviews highlight that Yōtei “beats Tsushima in every category” in many reviewers’ eyes.

    • GameSpot gave it 9/10, calling it a marked improvement on Tsushima.

    • Some dissenting voices exist (see below).

👎 Weaknesses, Criticisms & Caveats

  1. Repetitive / Generic Side Content
    Some missions or camps feel formulaic or too similar across the map. Generic “clear this outpost” or “defeat enemies in a location” quests are criticized for lacking narrative weight.

  2. Camera & Targeting Issues
    Occasionally enemies slip off screen or behind the camera during fast combats or projectile attacks, forcing the player to manually reorient — especially frustrating in tense fights.

  3. Open World Tropes & Clutter
    Even with the more organic approach, the game still has many open-world “icons to clear,” and some critics argue the map can feel overly busy or mechanical in places.

  4. Narrative Lulls / Pacing Issues
    Some reviews caution that the narrative sometimes drags, especially between key moments.

  5. Not All Innovations Pay Off
    Because the game builds heavily on Tsushima, some feel it doesn’t always step far enough beyond it to feel fresh in certain systems.
    Also, some stylistic modes and shifts may appeal more to some players than others.

  6. Mixed Criticism from Some Outlets
    For example, AV Club described it as “a big, beautiful bowl of gaming gruel,” suggesting that while impressive in scale and looks, it may feel dense, heavy, or overly familiar.

✅ Verdict & Who It’s For

Overall, Ghost of Yōtei is being received as a major success and a strong step forward from Ghost of Tsushima. It often outperforms its predecessor in visual, narrative, and mechanical dimensions (per reviewers).

If you enjoy:

  • Story-driven open-world/action games

  • Samurai / revenge narratives

  • Exploration, atmosphere, and visual immersion

  • A balance of stealth + direct combat

then Yōtei is likely to hit many of your sweet spots.

But if repetitive mission loops, occasional camera frustrations, or a desire for very radical innovation bother you, those are the areas to be cautious about.

 

Comments

Post a Comment